Skip to content
Shoresh Wiki

The edits no word count can catch

Every other audit on this site counts words. This one was built because the most effective rewrites do not move a countable word at all. Six structural detectors, pointed at the articles Wikipedia’s own arbitration regime flags as contested and its own projects rate Top or High importance, returned 53 findings. On the Palestine Liberation Organization, “Palestinian militant and political organization” became “Official representative of Palestinians”. On Marwan Barghouti, “convicted and imprisoned for murder by an Israeli court” left the first sentence and never came back to it. On Mahmoud al-Zahar, the line Google prints stopped saying he co-founded Hamas and started saying he was born in 1945. Not one of those edits trips a watchlist. Every one of them removes something a reader used to be able to learn.

A keyword list scores zero on the best case we have

Section titled “A keyword list scores zero on the best case we have”

Run a vocabulary test over the PLO article and it reports nothing. In 2005 the opening read “a political and paramilitary organization of Palestinian Arabs”. Today it reads “a Palestinian nationalist coalition that is internationally recognized as the official representative of the Palestinian people”. Paramilitary is not on anybody’s flagged-word list, and the words that replaced it are not accusations, slurs or errors. They are the vocabulary of statehood.

That is the mechanism. Reframing at this level works by deleting specificity and by conferring standing, and no vocabulary catches an absence. So the instrument does not ask which flagged word moved. It asks what the sentence used to let a reader work out, and whether it still does.

DetectorThe moveWhat a vocabulary test records
Agency deletionthe actor leaves the sentence, the deed staysnothing: no flagged word moved
Event-class softeningthe kind of event changes underneath the same factsa swap, and only when both words happen to be listed
Legitimacy grantstanding arrives: elected, recognised, official, representativewords added, scored neutral or positive
Attribution flipa fact becomes what one party says about itnothing: every word survives
Specificity deletiona rank, conviction, affiliation or role is cutnothing, unless the cut word was flagged
Deed turned into a noun”killed thirty civilians” becomes “the killing”nothing: the noun keeps the root

Direction is decided before anything is reported, using Wikipedia’s own project tags for whose article it is. A designation leaving an article about an armed Palestinian faction is a finding. A designation leaving an article about Israel is usually a correction, and it is filed as one. The method page sets out the zones and the reach weighting; the reach audit shows how much of the topic’s readership sits on articles already caught moving; the ledger lists the edits one by one.

Across the run: 987 scored changes, 53 findings, 58 corrections, 734 neutral, 142 sent for a human read.

The one line, reach 1.00

Section titled “The one line, reach 1.00”

The short description carries no citation and needs no consensus. It is what mobile prints under the heading, what search prints beside the result, what a knowledge panel lifts, and what a language model repeats when someone asks what a thing is.

Palestine Liberation Organization

Section titled “Palestine Liberation Organization”

then: Palestinian militant and political organization now: Official representative of Palestinians

Two edits, both logged by their authors in the field Wikipedia provides for exactly that. On 9 January 2025, at revision 1268453732, the editor Prezbo cut “Militant and political organization” down to “Palestinian nationalist coalition” under the summary “slightly more descriptive”. On 15 July 2025, at revision 1300700567, the editor Patar knight logged: “Changing short description from “Palestinian nationalist coalition” to “Official representative of Palestinians””. It is live at revision 1365200361.

A reader who meets the PLO in a search result now learns that it represents Palestinians and nothing else. Nothing in that line cues Ma’alot in 1974, where PLO gunmen took a school and murdered 22 children, or the Coastal Road attack in 1978, which killed 38 Israelis including 13 children.

Mahmoud al-Zahar

Section titled “Mahmoud al-Zahar”

then: Palestinian politician and physician; co-founder of Hamas now: Palestinian politician (born 1945)

One editor added it and the same editor took it out. Thepharoah17 imported the Hamas line from Wikidata in August 2021 at revision 1038247514, then on 26 May 2025, at revision 1292266729, made a short-description-only edit whose summary states the change in his own words: “Changing short description from “Palestinian politician and physician; co-founder of Hamas” to “Palestinian politician (born 1945)””. Still live at revision 1364952914.

The convention for biography short descriptions permits a birth year. It does not require deleting the affiliation to make room for one, and no other fact was touched in that edit. A founder of Hamas now indexes as a politician.

The defining sentence, reach 0.95

Section titled “The defining sentence, reach 0.95”

The “is a” phrase is not a fact about the subject. It is the category every other fact has to live in.

Palestine Liberation Organization

Section titled “Palestine Liberation Organization”

then, revision 9245187, 2005: “is a political and paramilitary organization of Palestinian Arabs dedicated to the establishment of an independent Palestinian state to consist of the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, with an intent to replace Israel” now, revision 1365200361: “is a Palestinian nationalist coalition that is internationally recognized as the official representative of the Palestinian people in the occupied Palestinian territories”

The drain and the fill are two consecutive edits by one editor on one day, 6 September 2023, a month before October 7. At revision 1174066671 TheDoodbly removed “militant” from “Palestinian nationalist political and militant organization”, under the summary “detailing”. At revision 1174067897, the next edit, the same editor installed “internationally recognized as the official representative of the Palestinian people”, under the summary “rewrite first para for more clarity”.

Deleting the word that says an organisation is armed was logged as detailing. Installing its diplomatic standing was logged as clarity. What the subject is recognised as now arrives before anything about how it fought, and the stated aim of replacing Israel is gone from the sentence that defines it.

Marwan Barghouti

Section titled “Marwan Barghouti”

then, revision 1154080698, 10 May 2023, the last version before 7 October: “is a Palestinian political figure convicted and imprisoned for murder by an Israeli court.” now, revision 1364535393: “is a Palestinian political leader who has served as an elected legislator and has been an advocate of a two-state solution since prior to his imprisonment by Israel.”

Two edits, both traceable. On 11 April 2024, at revision 1218373103, the editor Makeandtoss changed “convicted and imprisoned for murder by an Israeli court” to “convicted and imprisoned for his role in deadly attacks against Israel”, under the summary “more neutral phrasing per France24 and Associated Press”. The word murder and the Israeli court left the definition zone in one stroke, and the reason given was neutrality. On 23 March 2025, at revision 1281953871, the editor Jesswade88 cut the remaining conviction clause off the first sentence altogether and wrote in its place “An elected legislator and an advocate of a two-state compromise with Israel, he has been imprisoned by Israel since 2002”. The same edit deleted “becoming a leader of Tanzim, a paramilitary offshoot of Fatah” from the lead. Three days later, at revision 1282370397, “two-state compromise” was wikilinked as “two-state solution”.

The 2005 article, revision 18311382, opened by calling him a leader of Fatah and stating that he was serving five life sentences for murder and attempted murder. The current lead contains none of the words murder, terrorist, Tanzim or Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades.

Someone will point out that the conviction is not gone from the article, and that is the shape of the finding rather than an objection to it. The word murder appears seventeen times in the body of the Barghouti article and zero times in the lead. The surviving mention sits in the second paragraph, phrased as charges of “involvement in deadly attacks”, and is followed immediately by his denial and by a finding that his trial was unfair. The body is where a reader has to go looking. The first sentence is what the search result quotes, what the knowledge panel lifts, and what a chatbot recites: an elected two-state advocate whom Israel imprisoned for reasons the sentence never gives.

President of Palestine

Section titled “President of Palestine”

then, revision 648480545, 23 February 2015: “The President of the State of Palestine is the leader of the State of Palestine which was unilaterally declared in November 1988 by Palestinian Declaration of Independence of the Palestinian National Council of the Palestine Liberation Organization.” now, revision 1365871447: “The president of the State of Palestine (رئيس دولة فلسطين, Raʼīs Dawlat Filasṭīn) is the head of state of Palestine.”

One edit did it: revision 680192031, 9 September 2015, by the editor Qualitatis, summary “lead”, cutting the article from 4,334 bytes to 3,325. The comparison against its parent, revision 672981845, shows the unilateral declaration and the whole PLO chain removed from the opening in one pass. By revision 693573635 on 3 December 2015 the sentence already read “is the head of the State of Palestine”; a later edit upgraded that to the linked constitutional term “head of state”.

Two detectors fire on the same sentence. The declaring actor is gone, which is agency deletion, and the word unilaterally is gone, which is specificity deletion, and the word unilaterally now appears nowhere in the article at all. What remains reads as the ordinary head of state of an existing country. The qualifier that the post “is not validated by democratic elections, but rather by the PLO Central Council” survives in the body, at reach 0.25, where no search snippet and no language model goes.

Raed Al Karmi

Section titled “Raed Al Karmi”

then, revision 1179942980, 13 October 2023: “was a Palestinian terrorist and member of the Fatah’s Tanzim, a terror organization.” now: “was a Palestinian member of the Fatah’s Tanzim group.”

Sixteen days after October 7, on 23 October 2023, the editor Egeymi made a single edit, revision 1181465999, that deleted the designation twice, once from the man and once from the organisation, under the summary “removed distortions”. The article had carried “Palestinian terrorist” in its opening sentence for its entire life to that date, including at revision 1174445870 of 8 September 2023.

It had been defended repeatedly. Nableezy reverted a removal on 29 November 2021 with the summary “Reverted 1 edit by Doerksen: Arbpia”. Egeymi himself reverted an anonymous removal on 11 May 2022, and Drewtonium undid another on 22 January 2023. The word survived every one of those attempts. It came out for good in the fortnight after the largest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust, and it stayed out. Extended-confirmed protection arrived on 8 October 2025, two years too late to protect the sentence that mattered.

One minute after that edit, at revision 1181466101, the same editor changed “the killing of two Tel Aviv restaurant owners in Tulkarem” to “the killing of two Israeli settlers in Tulkarem”, under the summary “it is what the source says, if you have any source saying what you claimed then put it”. Two murdered civilians, recoded in the opening as settlers, and it is still there. The live text at revision 1319125325 now opens “was a leading member of Fatah’s (now disassociated) militant wing, the Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades”, which reads as a rank in an organisation the article no longer says is a terror organisation.

Palestinian nationalism

Section titled “Palestinian nationalism”

then, revision 9807770, 1 January 2005: “Palestinian nationalism, since the beginning of the 20th century, has centered on creating homelands for Arabs and Jews in Palestine, as part of distributing the territory controlled by the former Ottoman Empire after its defeat in World War I.” now, revision 1362027453: “Palestinian nationalism is the national movement of the Palestinian people that espouses self-determination and sovereignty over the region of Palestine.”

The arc runs in three steps and every one is on the record. At revision 279442667, 24 March 2009, the editor Historicist installed “the national movement of the Palestinian people” under the summary “replacing a badly muddled lede”, and those words survive verbatim today. At revision 430093687, 20 May 2011, an anonymous editor at the IP address 132.160.54.151 deleted both the dating, “arose in the mid nineteenth to early twentieth century”, and the attribution, “on the land that they regard as their historic national home”, in one edit, under the summary “Streamlined the lead. Took out vague statements.” At revision 1070890957, 9 February 2022, the editor Zeex.rice added “espouses … sovereignty over the region of Palestine” under “cleanup lead”. The sentence is byte-identical in the live revision 1368518274.

The load-bearing loss is the attribution. Land “that they regard as their historic national home” is a description of a claim held by a people. Flat “sovereignty over the region of Palestine” is Wikipedia asserting the claim’s object in its own voice. The 2005 sentence also told a reader that the subject was a twentieth-century process of allocating post-Ottoman territory between two peoples, Arabs and Jews. The Jews are no longer in the definition of the movement that formed in response to them.

What the reader has to scroll for, reach 0.25

Section titled “What the reader has to scroll for, reach 0.25”

Paradise Now

Section titled “Paradise Now”

then: “Their handlers from an unidentified terrorist group tell them the attack will take place the next day.” now: “Their handlers from an unidentified militant group tell them the attack will take place the next day.”

Changed on 18 March 2025 at revision 1281086313 by the editor EvansHallBear, under the summary “/* Plot */ NPOV”. The plot being summarised is two men strapped into explosive belts and sent to detonate fifteen minutes apart, so that the second bomb kills the police responding to the first.

That word had been fought for and won on the merits. On 18 July 2024 the editor Ediro183 changed “resistance group” to “terrorist group” with the summary “Fixed information. A resistance group does not commit suicide bombings targeting civilians”. Frost reverted it forty minutes later as unsourced. Buenovale restored it the same afternoon, citing the New York Times. Sourced and argued, it then stood for eight months and came out under three letters. A sourced description of a group that murders civilians was removed as a point of view, and the point of view that survived is that the group is militant.

Refusing is what makes the rest usable

Section titled “Refusing is what makes the rest usable”

Four machine leads on these articles died under human checking, and they died for reasons worth publishing.

Three of them were one edit on Paradise Now, revision 1215542969 of 25 March 2024, which split one sentence into two. The extraction captured only up to the first full stop, so it looked as though “about two Palestinian men preparing for a suicide attack in Israel” had been deleted. It is still there, verbatim, in the next sentence. The fourth was on Palestinian nationalism, where the extractor logged a hatnote as a short description. No short description existed on that article before January 2021; one was added where there had been none, at revision 999465676 on 10 January 2021, and it has not changed since. Nothing left the article. The instrument needs a null when the template is absent instead of falling through to the first hatnote, and any pre-2021 short-description lead on that page is the same artifact.

Across the run the instrument returned 53 findings and 58 corrections. Wikipedia walks back accusations against Israel about as often as it drains designations from theirs, by this instrument.

Two of those corrections are worth naming because the same six detectors found them. On Palestinian refugees, at revision 1352118752 of 2 May 2026, the editor TheDoodbly replaced an assertion that the descendants of 1948 refugees are refugees with UNRWA’s attributed definition, so the definition sentence now states the patrilineal inheritance rule, “the descendant of any male Palestinian citizen”, in Wikipedia’s own voice. That rule is the mechanism by which roughly 700,000 became 5.6 million, and it is now in the highest-reach prose on the page, live at revision 1366179798. On Jihadism, the definition read “a neologism for militant Islamic movements that are perceived as existentially threatening to the West” until revision 1250310762 of 9 October 2024, whose author wrote that it was “bizarre to define it as the perception of threat held by one particular group”, and revision 1358823686 of 11 June 2026, whose author wrote “Although “jihadism” is a word, the article is not about the word, but about the ideology”. It now reads “the ideology of modern, armed militant Islamic movements that seek to establish states based on Islamic principles”, live at revision 1363326605.

Ask what the reader can no longer learn

Section titled “Ask what the reader can no longer learn”

Nothing on this page is a falsehood inserted into Wikipedia. Every edit here is a deletion, a substitution or a promotion, each one defensible on its own in an edit summary of four words or fewer, and every one of them passes a vocabulary test without leaving a mark. Detailing. Clarity. Neutrality. Lead. NPOV. Removed distortions.

Put them end to end and the category the subject lives in has been changed. An organisation with a paramilitary wing and a stated intent to replace Israel is the official representative of a people. A man serving five life sentences is an elected legislator and a two-state advocate. A self-declared office is a head of state. A terrorist is a leading member. A co-founder of Hamas is a politician born in 1945. The old text is still on the servers, timestamped, signed and one click away, which is the only reason any of this can be shown at all.

Count words and these articles look clean. Ask what a reader can no longer learn from them and the answer is: who did it, what he was convicted of, what the organisation was, and who declared the state.

Section titled “Related pages”

Sources

Section titled “Sources”